As British warships bombarded Fort McHenry on September 13, 1814, Samuel Etting was among the American soldiers defending Baltimore. A private in Captain Joseph H. Nicholson's Baltimore Fencibles, he was slightly wounded during the attack.
His father, Solomon Etting, had helped prepare the city for the assault. Representing Baltimore's First Ward on the General Committee of Vigilance and Safety, he served on a three-man group charged with arranging a hospital or suitable accommodations for sick and wounded soldiers. He also assisted in efforts to arrange quarters for troops defending the city.
Despite his service, Maryland barred Solomon Etting from holding elected office because he was Jewish.
Born in York, Pennsylvania, in 1764, Etting was the son of a German Jewish immigrant. In 1782, at 18, he trained as a shochet, or Jewish ritual slaughterer, under Bernard Gratz, a prominent Jewish merchant and longtime friend of his father. He was possibly the first native-born American to qualify for the position.
Following the death of his first wife, Etting married Gratz's daughter Rachel in 1791 and moved to Baltimore, where he established himself as a merchant and civic leader.
Etting helped found the Baltimore Water Company and took an active role in the city's small Jewish community. In 1801, he and his uncle Levy Solomon purchased land already being used as Baltimore's first Jewish burial ground. Because the community had no legally incorporated congregation capable of owning property, they acquired the land in their own names, securing legal title on behalf of Baltimore's Jews.
The original burial ground eventually fell out of use, but Etting himself was buried in 1847 in a separate family cemetery on West North Avenue, which still exists today but is no longer used for burials.
Maryland's constitution, adopted in 1776, required public officeholders to declare belief in Christianity. Although the United States Constitution prohibited religious tests for federal office, it did not prevent states from imposing their own religious qualifications for public office.
In 1797, Etting and his father-in-law, Bernard Gratz, petitioned the Maryland legislature to remove the restriction, asking that Jews be "placed upon the same footing with other good citizens."
Their appeal failed. Etting submitted another petition in 1802, again without success.
When British forces threatened Baltimore twelve years later, the restriction remained in place.
In August 1814, British troops defeated American forces at Bladensburg, Maryland, before marching into Washington and setting fire to the Capitol, the White House and other government buildings.
Baltimore, an important commercial port and a major center of American privateering, was an obvious next target. The city began preparing its defenses against the anticipated British assault.
Etting was among the civilians entrusted with helping organize those preparations, while his son Samuel served with the Baltimore Fencibles at Fort McHenry.
On September 13, British warships opened fire on the fort, beginning a bombardment that lasted approximately 25 hours.
Despite the shells and rockets directed against them, the American defenders held their positions. Unable to force the fort's surrender or overcome Baltimore's defenses, the British abandoned their attack.
The sight of the American flag still flying over Fort McHenry the following morning inspired Francis Scott Key to write the poem that eventually became "The Star-Spangled Banner."
Jewish participation in the war would soon become an argument in the campaign to overturn Maryland's religious restrictions.
In a speech to the General Assembly on January 20, 1819, legislator Thomas Kennedy pointed to the service of Jewish soldiers during the recent conflict.
They had stood "in the ranks by the side of their Christian brethren," he declared, fighting for a state that continued to deny them equal political rights.
Kennedy, who had begun championing Jewish political equality the previous year, faced fierce opposition. His efforts to remove the religious restrictions were repeatedly defeated, and he lost his legislative seat in 1823 before returning to office and renewing the campaign.
The consequences of Maryland's religious restrictions were not confined to elected office.
In a speech in 1824, legislator William G. D. Worthington recounted an incident involving Etting and one of his sons.
The young man had expressed a desire to study law, but Maryland's requirements stood in his way. Unless he renounced Judaism, he could not practice as an attorney, even in a county court.
"The Father, with pain in his heart and tears in his eyes, told him he could not," Worthington recalled.
That year, Etting joined his uncle Levy Solomon and fellow Jewish businessman Jacob I. Cohen Jr. in submitting another petition to the Maryland legislature.
Etting also supplied Worthington with information about Maryland's Jewish population, including its economic contributions, military service and participation in public affairs.
After years of unsuccessful attempts, the legislation popularly known as the "Jew Bill" passed the Maryland legislature in February 1825 by the narrowest of margins, with the House of Delegates approving it by a single vote, 26 to 25. It received the required confirmation the following year.
The law enabled Jews to hold public office without professing Christianity, instead allowing them to affirm their belief in "reward and punishment" in order to serve. For Etting and Maryland's small Jewish community, it marked the end of a struggle that had lasted nearly three decades.
In October 1826, Solomon Etting and Jacob I. Cohen Jr. were elected to the Baltimore City Council, becoming the first Jewish elected officials in Maryland.
Etting subsequently became president of the council's First Branch, assuming a leadership position in the very government from which he had long been excluded.
For twelve years, Etting had lived with a remarkable contradiction: Maryland had welcomed his help in defending Baltimore but denied him the right to help govern it. His election in 1826 finally put an end to that injustice.

